12 Best Drugstore Eyeliners for 2023 (2023)

Enter a fancy beauty salon andlose the equivalent of a cell phone billfor a new makeup product is easy. But it's not always the most fiscally responsible thing to do for beauty girls. Yes, there is something good in waste. But those little personal care purchases add up. But that's why we're here to reiterate that there are pocket brands out there competing with premium alternatives.

Say hello to the pharmacy niche. For many of us, this is where we first tested our makeup skills when our parents let us play with cosmetics. Plus, the lower price and consistent availability at brick-and-mortar retailers make the drugstore beauty brand an attractive option, regardless of age or income level.

Take a look at our most recommended drugstore eyeliners and get ready to shop. But first, readour guideCheck out the main types of eyeliner to determine which one is right for you.

Overview of the best drugstore eyeliner:

  • Best overall: Rimmel London Exagerate Waterproof Eye Definer
  • Best budget: Essence Cosmetics Long Lasting Eye Pencil
  • Best for Smokey Eyes: Milani Stay Put Eyeliner
  • Best improvement: Physicians Formula Eye Booster Lash 2 in 1 Enhancing Eyeliner Serum
  • The best colors: Caneta Pixi Endless Beauty Silky Eye
  • Best Gel Jar:Maybelline Eyestudio Lasting Drama Gel Eyeliner
  • Best for Beginners: NYX Cosmetics Epic Ink Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner
  • Best waterproof: Delineador Revlon ColorStay
  • Best microphone:Elf. Cosmetics No Budge Precision Eyeliner
  • Best matte: Wet n Wild MegaLast Break-Resistant Liquid Eyeliner
  • Best chart: Delineador fosco L.A. Girl Line Art
  • Best Classic: CoverGirl Perfect Blend Eyeliner Pencil

How We Picked the Best Drugstore Eyeliners

To compile this list, we researched manufacturer specifications, including type, formula, color range, and more, to create a short list of the best drugstore eyeliners. We then comb through detailed product descriptions, ratings, and reviews to find the best drugstore eyeliners for each category.

Our Picks for the Best Drugstore Eyeliners

1

better overall

Rimmel London Exagerate Waterproof Eye Definer

12 Best Drugstore Eyeliners for 2023 (1)

$ 6,97

what we love

  • 6 tons
  • built-in smoker
  • 10 hours long

what we don't love

  • It can stain oily skin

Rimmel London Exaggerate Waterproof Eye Definer is an excellent choice for professionals and beginners alike, thanks to its smooth, glide-on texture. It offers a commendable range of shades that includes six metallic and matte shades.

This retractable gel pen comes with a built-in smoker and promises up to 10 hours of long-lasting waterproof wear. However, some reviewers have noted that this liner can smudge oily skin after a while.

Type and formula:shrink gel |Cores:6 |Finish:metallic matte |Waterproof:Sim

2

best budget

Essence Cosmetics Long Lasting Eye Pencil

12 Best Drugstore Eyeliners for 2023 (2)

$ 2,99

what we love

  • Vegan and free of oils, parabens, fragrances and alcohol.
  • 7 tons
  • Accessible

what we don't love

  • not waterproof

If you're on a really tight budget or just don't want to break the bank, the Essence Cosmetics Longwear Eye Pencil is a solid choice. This retractable gel pen is free of oils, parabens, fragrances, and alcohol with a cruelty-free and vegan formula.

The product comes in seven shades, so you can choose between classic shades and bold sparkles.

Type and formula:shrink gel |Cores:7 |Finish:partner |Waterproof:No

3

Best for smoky eyes

Milani Stay Put Eyeliner

12 Best Drugstore Eyeliners for 2023 (3)

US$9.99

what we love

  • built-in smoker
  • Waterproof
  • 5 tons

what we don't love

  • There is no clear timeline for long clothing on the list

(Video) Testing the BEST Drugstore Waterproof Eyeliner Pencils (Waterline, Smoky Eye, Smudge-Proof)

Milani is a fan favorite on the drugstore circuit as one of the few traditional brands that has historically embraced all skin tones. Stay Put Eyeliner is an ideal choice if you like to switch between a classic eyeliner look or a smokey eye. The creamy retractable gel pen also has a built-in smoker.

We like that this pick is waterproof and sweatproof, with claims that you can even take a dip in the pool while wearing it. Due to the retractable design, you never have to worry about reachingsharp lines.

Type and formula:shrink gel |Cores:5 |Finish:partner |Waterproof:Sim

4

best improvement

Physicians Formula Eye Booster Lash 2-in-1 Eyeliner and Enhancer Serum

12 Best Drugstore Eyeliners for 2023 (4)

$ 11,49

what we love

  • Liquid felt-tip formula
  • 2-in-1 formula to stimulate eyelash growth.
  • easy application

what we don't love

  • Grey-black finish instead of jet black
  • New Formula May Affect Efficacy

Imagine an eyeliner that can do more than just line your eyes. Physicians Formula has the answer you're looking for with Eye Booster Lash 2-in-1 Boosting Eyeliner & Serum. This felt-tip liquid eyeliner features a dual formula designed to make your eyes pop and exhilarate.eyelash growth.

Since it is an eyeliner, you can get as close as possible to the base of the lashes, which is also ideal for applying the serum. The brand promises that this selection features a high-tech Japanese formula that is not only long-lasting but also resistant to water and smudges.

However, some reviewers noted a formula change that caused the product to come off like an eyeliner. Also, many people have mentioned that the color is more of a grayish black than a true dark black.

Type and formula:Felt Tip Liquid |Cores:1 |Finish:partner |Waterproof:Sim

5

best colors

Caneta Pixi Endless Beauty Silky Eye

12 Best Drugstore Eyeliners for 2023 (5)

$ 12

what we love

  • Wide range of shades of 23 colors.
  • Silky gel formula for a flawless application.
  • Waterproof and long lasting.

what we don't love

  • Total hours of extended use not specified

Not everyone wants to wear black or brown eyeliner every day for the rest of their lives. If you like to accentuate your eyes with pops of color in addition to eyeshadow, you'll love this wide range of shades in Pixi Beauty's Endless Silky Eye Pen.

(Video) The best drugstore lip combo #shorts

These are traditional gel pens that offer a waterproof, long-lasting, smudge-free, and smudge-free experience. While the brand can't quantify how many hours of extended wear it can achieve, we like that the creamy formula makes application easy and skip-free.

Type and formula:gel pen |Cores:23 |Finish:partner |Waterproof:Sim

6

best gel jar

Maybelline Eyestudio Lasting Drama Gel Eyeliner

12 Best Drugstore Eyeliners for 2023 (6)

US$9.99

what we love

  • 24 hour long-lasting formula.
  • Comes with applicator brush
  • oil free formula

what we don't love

  • Light learning curve for a perfect application
  • only 2 shades

If you're not intimidated by a bottle of gel, try Maybelline's entry into this product category. The Eyestudio Lasting Drama Gel Eyeliner is a game changer that any seasoned makeup lover or beginner needs in their arsenal. We like that this pick comes with a precision brush so you don't have to buy one separately.

While a traditional bottle of gel can challenge your drawing skills, we like the ink's color payoff and the promise of up to 24 hours of smudge-resistant wear. The oil-free, waterproof formula glides easily onto lids. Although there are only two colors, we believe that it is a must.

Type and formula:ice boots |Cores:2 |Finish:partner |Waterproof:Sim

7

best for beginners

NYX Cosmetics Epic Ink Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner

12 Best Drugstore Eyeliners for 2023 (7)

$ 10

what we love

  • Precision Tip Applicator Brush
  • Waterproof and long lasting.
  • vegan formula

what we don't love

  • The new formula may have changes in consistency
  • only 2 shades

While some say a classic pencil is the best choice for eyeliner beginners, we disagree. We think it's a tie between gel pencils and felt-tip liquid eyeliners. So if traditional liquid eyeliners give you butterflies, NYX Cosmetics Epic Ink Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner is a great alternative.

This precision-tipped eyeliner lets you make thick and thin lines, and the flexible brush tip glides over skin for easy application. Meanwhile, the vegan formula is designed to be long-lasting and is perfect for cat eyes,basicand graphic coatings. But a word of caution, some reviews have mentioned that a change in the formula makes the consistency runnier.

Type and formula:Felt Tip Liquid |Cores:2 |Finish:partner |Waterproof:Sim

8

best waterproof

Delineador Revlon ColorStay

12 Best Drugstore Eyeliners for 2023 (8)

$ 9,69

(Video) If I could only keep 5 DRUGSTORE makeup products.. 👀

what we love

  • Shrinkable and waterproof gel formula.
  • 24 hours of use
  • Comes with a built-in sharpener

what we don't love

  • weak color reward

Revlon's ColorStay Eyeliner claims to stay on for up to 24 hours, a waterproof formula that comes in eight vivid shades. This is a retractable gel pen that has a built-in sharpener at the other end to give you precision when you need it.

However, some reviewers have noted that the pigment is not very opaque and you may need to redo your lines for better color payoff.

Type and formula:shrink gel |Cores:8 |Finish:partner |Waterproof:Sim

9

best mic

Elf. Cosmetics No Budge Precision Eyeliner

12 Best Drugstore Eyeliners for 2023 (9)

$ 6,00

what we love

  • micro precision tip
  • Long lasting and smudge proof.
  • shrink gel formula

what we don't love

  • not waterproof

If you are trying to make tight lines or want to make more precise lines, you need a micro eyeliner pencil. Elf. Cosmetics No Budge Precision Eyeliner is the answer to your prayers.

In addition to being ridiculously affordable, cruelty-free, and vegan, this wallet liner features a shrink gel design in a micro size that's perfect for getting into tight spaces. Plus, you'll get a long-wearing formula that's smudge-proof, too.

Type and formula:shrink gel |Cores:1 |Finish:partner |Waterproof:No

10

better mate

Wet n Wild MegaLast Break-Resistant Liquid Eyeliner

12 Best Drugstore Eyeliners for 2023 (10)

US$ 6,99

what we love

  • Black matte finish with real ink.
  • Water resistant, up to 16 hours of use
  • Precision tip for thick or thin lines

what we don't love

  • Only available in 1 color

If you like the idea of ​​a liquid eyeliner but are often frustrated by lesser applying options like gray, this product from Wet n Wild is the answer. MegaLast Breakup-Proof Liquid Eyeliner is a felt-tip version of the brand's iconic traditional liquid liner,Megaliner.

The beginner-friendly formula delivers an inked-on matte black finish using a precision applicator tip, allowing you to create thick or thin lines with ease. Like the original formula, it's also waterproof, promising up to 16 hours of wear (minus the learning curve).

Type and formula:Felt Tip Liquid |Cores:1 |Finish:partner |Waterproof:Sim

11

best graphic

Delineador fosco L.A. Girl Line Art

12 Best Drugstore Eyeliners for 2023 (11)

US$7.99

what we love

  • Precision tip for graphic eyeliners
  • Available in 4 colors
  • Waterproof and smudge proof

what we don't love

  • No details on the length of the claim for long garments

(Video) Best Eyeliner Tips

If you like graphic eyeliners, you know that having a precision tip for your eyeliner is essential. OVER THERE. Chica has you covered with the brand's Line Art Matte Eyeliner.

Available in four colors, you'll get a fine point so sharp you'll be able to deftly cut into folds and everything in between. This is a felt-tip liquid eyeliner in a vegan waterproof formula that promises to be smudge-proof and long-lasting.

Type and formula:Felt Tip Liquid |Cores:4 |Finish:partner |Waterproof:Sim

12

best classic

CoverGirl Perfect Blend Eyeliner Pencil

12 Best Drugstore Eyeliners for 2023 (12)

$ 4,52

what we love

  • built-in smoker
  • waterproof formula
  • Comes in 4 shades

what we don't love

  • No details on the claim for long garments

We're rounding out our top picks with a nod to a classic eyeliner. If you're not ready for gels and liquids yet, you can't go wrong with the traditional pencil.

CoverGirl's Perfect Blend Eyeliner Pencil comes with a built-in smoker on the opposite end to create smoky eyes. Choose from four shades in this waterproof formula.

Type and formula:Pencil|Cores:4 |Finish:partner |Waterproof:Sim

Align and define like a pro

Eyeliner is a staple in almost every makeup routine, and there's no reason to skip it because you can't afford mid-range or luxury brands. Drugstore brand eyeliner comes in many forms, including traditional pencils, gels, creams, and liquids. Meanwhile, there is something for everyone with the wide range of colors and formulas available. If you're looking for a great retractable gel pen, Rimmel London's Exaggerate Waterproof Eye Definer is a solid choice with a wide range of shades and a built-in smoker.

How to Choose the Right Drugstore Eyeliner for You

Drugstore eyeliners should be affordable, but you can't stop there. Think about the type of formula you want to use, as well as whether the shade range, longevity, and durability claims are compatible with your needs.

Formula

Eyeliner formulas often revolve around traditional pencils, gels, and liquids. We've only included a classic pencil formula because these days it seems like gel pencils have replaced the old-school options.

gel eyelinersthey are ideal because they are less likely to skip when you apply them. However, depending on your applicator design, you may need to consider how easily you can sharpen the tip for greater precision. Gels can include gel pens and gel pots, which require a brush to apply properly.

liquid eyelinerFormulas can be divided into classic liquid and felt-tipped. Of all the formulas, the liquid one has the biggest learning curve, especially the traditional liquid pots. But liquid formulas tend to offer the best matte finish and hold. If classic canisters are intimidating, opt for felt-tip alternatives, which give you the control of a pencil, but with bolder color and precision thanks to the fine-tipped applicator.

sharpness and point

Depending on the type of eyeliner design you're trying, sharpness and tip are important. For a classic eyeliner look, sharpness isn't as critical. But if you're trying out a cat, wing, or graphic eyeliner, you'll want a precise application. As mentioned above, felt-tip liquid eyeliners (either bottle or pen) are ideal for more detailed applications.

However, gel canisters, as long as you use an angled brush, offer precision as well. Microgel retractable pencils are also great because the miniature size of the pen head ensures that you always have a precision tip. For other gel pens, look for a built-in sharpener or invest in one so you can use it as needed.

Elimination

Eyeliner removal can be easy or difficult depending on the formula. Most of the recommendations in our guide are waterproof formulas, which require a little more effort to remove. While many people try to rely on baby wipes to clean their faces, this isfast but not complete. The wipes remove what you see, but they don't clean the pores. That's why they shouldn't be your only cleansing option if you wear makeup.

More importantly, the wipes tend to be ill-equipped to remove more serious waterproof formulas. Instead, you'll want to use acleansing balmomicellar waterthis is safe for your eyes. Balms emulsify in oils, which can better penetrate heavy makeup and break it down so you can easily rinse it off with water or wipe it off with a cloth. Meanwhile, micellar waters are effective at breaking down makeup. Both balms and micellar waters support a more traditional cleansing method that removes makeup from pores to prevent breakouts.

Frequent questions

What is the best rated drugstore eyeliner?

The best rating is irrelevant if it doesn't work for you. Think about your skin type when shopping for eyeliners. Also consider the color result and finish you want. For example, many gel formulas are not compatible with oily skin, as oily skin can promote blemishes. Instead, matte, oil-free, and fade-proof formulas are best for this particular skin type.

Which eyeliner should a beginner buy?

The simplest eyeliners will be those of pencil or pen format. Gel pens are great for beginners, as they often feature skip-proof formulas that apply easily. In the meantime, if you're feeling more adventurous, a felt-tip liquid liner can help you achieve more precise looks like cat eyes, graphic liner, and wings.

What is a good eyeliner that lasts all day?

It depends on your body chemistry. While you should look for a waterproof formula that promises to be shatterproof, keep in mind that this varies by skin type and the individual.

(Video) TOP 10 Eyeliners in THE WORLD (according to you)

Videos

1. The Most Underrated Drugstore Makeup
(Taylor Margaret)
2. Best Drugstore Makeup of ALL TIME! | Dominique Sachse
(Dominique Sachse)
3. Best drugstore eyeliner! #affordablemakeup
(JESSICA MAAS)
4. BEST eyeliner!! #makeup #shorts
(a.j_artistry)
5. BEST DRUGSTORE FOUNDATIONS OF 2023
(Ale Jay)
6. I bought all the NEW VIRAL drugstore makeup.. whats good? whats trash?
(Laura Lee)
Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Nathanial Hackett

Last Updated: 30/03/2023

Views: 5922

Rating: 4.1 / 5 (52 voted)

Reviews: 83% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Nathanial Hackett

Birthday: 1997-10-09

Address: Apt. 935 264 Abshire Canyon, South Nerissachester, NM 01800

Phone: +9752624861224

Job: Forward Technology Assistant

Hobby: Listening to music, Shopping, Vacation, Baton twirling, Flower arranging, Blacksmithing, Do it yourself

Introduction: My name is Nathanial Hackett, I am a lovely, curious, smiling, lively, thoughtful, courageous, lively person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.